Call Us Toll Free: 614-888-4491

Our Story

From Passion to Obsession

It’s Not Your Every Day Brownie® Company

Everybody wants a Sugardaddy – brownie, that is. Or at least that’s what Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties® Co-Founders, Tom Finney and Mark Ballard, firmly believed.

Tom’s passion for creating special-occasion goodies led to the development of the original brownie collection and Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties® in his Westerville, Ohio kitchen in 2003.

Unlike any other brownies, the Edgeless Brownies® were round, uniformly moist, and sumptuously chewy.

Lisa Anglim - Owner of Sugardaddy's

Owner Lisa Anglim

Mark and Tom developed a business plan to market a full line of Couture Brownies® and blondies.  Together, they launched Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties® in time to celebrate Sweetest Day on October 15, 2005.

Ten years after the conception of the original Sugardaddy’s brand, Lisa and Dan Anglim, a Columbus, Ohio, couple, took over the reigns with a new vision for delivering Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties to adoring fans far and wide.

Executive Chef Martin Moran

Executive Chef Martin Moran

Executive Chef Martin Moran joined Sugardaddy’s in 2014  after serving as Culinary Coordinator for Sur La Table at Easton, Executive Sous and Pastry Chef for The Refectory Restaurant in Columbus, Ohio, as well as Executive Chef for Le Bistro du Beaujolais in Westlake, Ohio. Chef Moran enjoys all cuisines and preparing them at home especially for his two children, Tommy and Jack.

Consistently using premium ingredients and meticulously ensuring the freshly-baked quality, Sugardaddy’s award-winning brownies and brownie products are delivered nationwide from orders placed online and baked to order.

The flagship store adjacent to the bakery offers a delightful assortment daily.

Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties serves Central Ohio businesses with their Corporate Concierge gifting service.  Custom-branded packaging for freshly-baked Sugardaddy’s treats makes a memorable impression on clients and prospects.


For more complex orders and corporate monogramming, we would be happy to assist you with our complimentary Corporate Services. Just call us, toll free, to get started: 614-888-4491

Flavor of the Month

  • Fiery Brunette — January 1 - January 31
  • The Redhead (Red Velvet Brownie) — February 1 - February 28
  • Irish Stout Brunette — March 1 - March 31
  • Cherry Almond Blonde — April 1 - April 30
  • Strawberry Blonde — May 1 - June 30
  • Chai Spiced Blonde — September 1 - October 31
  • Harvest Blonde — October 1 - November 30
  • Midnight Brunette - December 1 - December 31

 We bake a small quantity of all flavors to produce our Brownie Truffles in all flavor selections year round.

Save & Share Cart
Your Shopping Cart will be saved and you'll be given a link. You, or anyone with the link, can use it to retrieve your Cart at any time.
Back Save & Share Cart
Your Shopping Cart will be saved with Product pictures and information, and Cart Totals. Then send it to yourself, or a friend, with a link to retrieve it at any time.
Your cart email sent successfully :)